Reimagining and rebuilding the federal government: the role of social scientists in evidence-backed U.S. policymaking

The Washington Center for Equitable Growth earlier this month convened a panel of scholars and former senior officials at the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management’s Fall Research Conference in Boston, titled “Reimagining and Rebuilding Government: The Role of Social Scientists in Evidence-Backed Policymaking.” Held on November 6, our APPAM discussion explored how social scientists can help rebuild the capacity of the federal government and public trust in it at a moment when both are under severe strain.
Opening the session, Korin Davis, Equitable Growth’s director of academic programs, described the dual tasks facing the field. Tens of thousands of civil servants have either left government or been pushed out, federal statistical agencies are being systematically weakened, and trust in government is low. Yet Davis framed the moment as an opportunity to reimagine what kind of government Americans want and to rebuild the workforce and institutions needed to deliver it.
Diagnosing the trust deficit and charting a path forward
Alondra Nelson, the Harold F. Linder Professor of Social Science and founding director of the Science, Technology, and Social Values Lab at the Institute for Advanced Study, opened the discussion by arguing that the founding assumption that scientific autonomy inherently serves the public interest has not been fully borne out and indeed no longer holds. Movements as different as the Aids Coalition to Unleash Power in the 1980s and today’s Make American Healthy Again movement, she noted, reflect a public that feels research has not responded to its needs. She asked what it would mean to revive the congressional Office of Technology Assessment, which advised the legislative branch from 1974 to 1995, but also charge the reconstituted office with bringing the public’s voice directly into its analysis. Her central point: commitment to democratic participation and accountability cannot come second to reforming government.
Sharon Block, professor of practice and executive director of the Center for Labor and a Just Economy at Harvard Law School, drew on decades of work across Congress, federal agencies, the White House, and the National Labor Relations Board to argue that trust requires public participation. She said that the federal government must do more to bring people along rather than simply announce policies.
Block then highlighted an overlooked asymmetry in administrative law: Regulations are easy to challenge, but inaction is not. Low-wage workers harmed by a failure to raise the overtime threshold, for example, have little recourse. Similarly, the notice-and-comment process is nominally open to all, but participation requires resources that corporations have and workers often do not. She proposed establishing an office of worker advocacy that would provide services to workers in a similar fashion to the support the U.S. Small Business Administration offers to small business owners and entrepreneurs.
Alex Hertel-Fernandez, the Herbert H. Lehman Professor of Government at Columbia University and a visiting fellow at Equitable Growth, explained why a Marshall Plan for the federal government would capture the scale of what is needed. The goal, he argued, is not simply to rebuild but to create institutions suited to the future. He outlined three roles for social scientists:
- Capture lost expertise through case studies, models, and lessons learned from those leaving government
- Staff surge teams for a future administration that will need many new people on day one, scaling tools such as Intergovernmental Personnel Act assignments that have so far been ad hoc
- Lay the groundwork now, recognizing that a sustainable, equitable effort will ultimately require Congress and dedicated appropriations
Jordan Matsudaira, who served in the Obama and Biden administrations before founding the Postsecondary Education and Economics Research Center at American University, described how staffing was the real bottleneck to efforts on student loan relief and oversight of private colleges at the U.S. Department of Education. The department held unique data, but bringing in analysts meant clearing steep hiring hurdles and relying on outside partners. Centers such as PEER can help, he said, but they cannot fill the void. There is no substitute for in-house expertise. He suggested that those launching similar efforts should start with the problems people inside government are trying to solve and work backwards.
Elizabeth Linos, founder of The People Lab at the Harvard Kennedy School, compared the pejorative narrative that U.S. government workers are lazy and inept to Greece’s recent era of austerity after the country’s sovereign debt crisis in 2009, when calls for public sector reform were paired with attacks that blamed public servants. The federal government cannot solve the problems facing our nation without the capacity to deliver, she argued, and reform cannot succeed while disparaging the people needed to carry it out.
Building trust, she continued, means proving it through better everyday interactions with government and investing in government’s capacity to learn, with evidence that is useful, usable, and used. She pointed to the Presidential Management Fellows program at the White House Office of Personnel Management as a proven recruitment and retention model worth reestablishing after the second Trump administration terminated it in February 2025, and noted that the resilience of the federal workforce depends not only on pay but also on support, workplace relationships, and a sense that the work matters.
From vision to practice: Who helps rebuild, and how
Equitable Growth’s Davis then turned to the role of universities, noting that institutions with vast endowments face their own crisis of public trust and perceptions that they serve only elites. Panelists agreed that universities have a part to play. They are regional anchors, major employers, and large landholders whose community relationships matter even in tight financial times. Panelists pointed to the well-established land-grant model, which pairs research with extension work in communities, and suggested creating incentives for faculty to do more of that public-facing work. Harvard Law School’s Block added that well-resourced universities should show the public, in collaboration with government, that their work delivers real value on problems that matter to people outside their walls.
On disciplinary diversity, Columbia University’s Hertel-Fernandez observed that the federal government already has strong platforms for economists, such as the White House Council of Economic Advisers, but far fewer for other social scientists. Some of the most valuable knowledge for policymaking has come from conceptual frameworks such as administrative burden, and from qualitative, ethnographic, and interview-based research that revealed new forms of burden.
Harvard Law’s Block then stressed that a broad view of expertise is essential for implementation. People with organizing backgrounds at the U.S. Department of Labor, for instance, help ensure workers actually learn about new policies and their rights. Low uptake, she noted, is not just a messaging problem.
The moderated discussion and audience Q&A sparked rich conversation on several themes:
- Research built for implementation. Harvard Kennedy School’s Linos noted a deep disconnect between what academic papers provide and what policymakers need and asked whether papers could be written to favor implementation. Panelists pointed to preregistration as proof that research norms can shift, and Hertel-Fernandez urged academics to better document what has already been tried.
- Readiness for bold ideas. Once an administration begins, the work focuses on execution. To engage in policy development, American University’s Matsudaira encouraged academics to engage with campaigns, and Hertel-Fernandez stressed having ideas ready when windows for large-scale change open.
- Participation at the right time, in the right way. Hertel-Fernandez observed that government often seeks public input after decisions are made and asks the wrong questions, leaving no room for lived experience. Panelists called for engagement that is not extractive and that puts the burden on government, not people, to connect residents with help.
- New career pathways. If serving in the federal government is no longer a 30-year career, then movement between government and academia can carry implementation knowledge back and forth. Panelists suggested inviting government workers into academic settings and building real onboarding for newcomers from both academia and the private sector.
- Countering the “government has no ideas” narrative. Panelists saw the core argument behind the White House’s short-lived DOGE Service, that government lacks ideas and talent, as one to confront directly, including by rebuilding the public image of capable civil servants.
Looking ahead
The panel closed with a discussion of policy windows. Matsudaira pointed to presidential primaries as opportunities to advocate for and influence more expansive policy ideas. Hertel-Fernandez built on that point, noting that policy moments come around periodically and that those with ideas need to be at the ready to capitalize on those windows through well-timed policy and media outreach.
The overarching point made by the panelists was that social scientists have a clear role to play in ensuring that new government programs and policies are grounded in evidence and embed democratic participation that work toward a more equitable future.
Whether you’re already connected with Equitable Growth or new to our work, we welcome you to reach out directly and let us know your specific interests in helping shape the next governing moment, and we’ll be in touch.
*Anthropic PBC’s AI tool Claude helped draft this column
Did you find this content informative and engaging?
Get updates and stay in tune with U.S. economic inequality and growth!
Stay updated on our latest research